Skip to content


Leave us your own review:

I can’t give them enough kudos

I just wanted to express how impressed I have been with my experience at The Crilly Agency the past few years. First of all, I love the staff at my agency and can’t give them enough kudos. Of course they are professional and knowledgeable, but what has been more impressive to me is their sincerity and patience. I have gone to my agent Pamela Lewis many times with questions and I’ve never felt rushed, she has always genuinely wanted me to understand how my policy works and I appreciate that immensely. With her help we have worked out exactly what kind of policies and coverages I need for where I am in life. I feel comfortable that if there is an unfortunate event in my life (knock on wood) those policies will be there to work for me and my agency will be the ones helping me with the process.

Thank you so much,

Brittney Vance

Continued and Outstanding Service

I just wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for the continued and outstanding insurance services that you provide for my family and I. I have been a customer of  The Crilly Agency/Nationwide Insurance for over 30 years and you have always been there to assist me with any questions, concerns or services that I may need. I cannot express enough, the gratitude I have for you and all you do for us. The slogan, “Nationwide is by your side” certainly is upheld to the highest. You have always served my family and I with the utmost respect and customer service that a person could receive. Your knowledge and professionalism of the insurance industry is A+. I appreciate you and the Peter Crilly Agency for the outstanding services you continue to provide. 

Thank you,

Traci Kent


Exceptional Service!!!

Excellent, prompt service! The kind of service that Nationwide/The Crilly Agency provides over and over again.

Finally! I found an insurance agent who is prompt, knowledgeable, efficient, and friendly, always finding me the best deal. Nationwide saved me and my sister Racquel hundreds of dollars.

I have worked with Mrs. Souders on many occasions. She is extremely prompt and very good at her job. Any time I have a question or concern with my insurance policies she works on my concerns right away and we were always able to resolve any difficulties that might have arisen; especially what we are currently dealing with as a whole County with Covid-19. I would highly recommend her and her company to anyone that wants a professional that takes their work seriously.

Nationwide has my complete satisfaction and has always been on my side; I have been a proud member since 2008.

Stephanie Dade

19 Years of Responsive Service

I have been a client of Peter B Associates/ The Crilly Agency for nineteen years.  The staff is responsive and have always looked for deals and options to lower our automobile rates as our kids became licensed drivers.  We also have property insurance.  I highly recommend this company and thank you, Peter, for a job well done and your excellent customer service over the years.

Marcus and Tracie Jennings

Dave Smith is the Best

Completely recommend this agency! Dave Smith helped my family and I save a great deal on our policy. Have been working with him for years…he is the BEST!

Jennifer Grimm

Five Stars for the Crilly Agency

I would highly recommend Peter B. Crilly & Associates Nationwide Insurance for all your family’s insurance needs. My family has been doing business with Dave Smith and Shellie Souders many many years. Nothing but exceptional service!!! Thank you so much Dave and Shellie for always looking out for my family’s best interests. You have never let us down!!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Joann Zornes

Like Family

Kathy Gascon is the absolute best!! Since the day I met her 15 years ago, I haven’t even thought about speaking to any other agent. I recommend to everyone I know. She’s definitely created a lifelong customer, fan, and friend in me. She’s family!!

Stephanie Linger

Detail and Personal Attention

I have relied on Dave Smith for decades. From my IRA, to my life insurance coverage, Dave has always done a fantastic job, and he takes the time to explain everything and help me do what’s best for me and my family. If it’s personal attention to detail you are looking for, Dave Smith is your guy.

Dawn Evans Hinkley

Great Team

I  have been working with this team for years and love them. Special shout out to Dave Smith and Shellie Souders for always having my back. Dealing with this team is always about what is the best for my family.

Jeff Egolf

Five Star Service

They are truly the best.  Five stars

Kelly Cox

Amazing Service

Nothing short of amazing. I am truly grateful and can honestly say that Kathy and the team always makes me feel like family. And they’ve met all my needs!!

Thank you so much!!

Cosuelo Pack